Part One / Page 8

‍

6. Legal & Regulatory Compliance

Jurisdiction and Legal Structure

Monero is a decentralized open-source project without any corporate issuer or controlling entity. There is no centralized “Monero Inc.”; instead, development is driven by volunteer contributors and community funding (via the Community Crowdfunding System). Legally, XMR is generally treated as a cryptocurrency/commodity rather than a security, because there is no investment contract or profit-sharing promise akin to an ICO. Thus, Monero itself largely falls outside securities regulations (similar to Bitcoin/Ether). No major jurisdiction has labeled XMR as a security. However, privacy features subject it to additional legal scrutiny beyond what transparent coins face. Because there is no issuing company, there is also no corporate governance structure or legal domicile for Monero, complicating accountability but reinforcing its censorship resistance.

Securities Law

In the U.S. and most countries, Monero would not be considered a “security” under Howey test principles: it had no ICO or sale of equity-like tokens, and purchasers do not expect profits from a central management team. Thus, Monero is analogous to Bitcoin (a commodity). The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) would likely classify XMR as a commodity, and indeed, regulators have not treated Monero transactions (aside from illicit uses) as securities offerings. No enforcement actions against Monero for securities law violations are known. Some analysts note that privacy coins are often discouraged on regulated platforms not for securities reasons but for AML reasons (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap) (Monero price today, XMR to USD live price, marketcap and chart | CoinMarketCap). For example, Coinbase has explicitly refused to list XMR not due to securities concerns but compliance: “because of its nature as a privacy coin, XMR isn’t supported by Coinbase” (Monero price today, XMR to USD live price, marketcap and chart | CoinMarketCap). In short, XMR’s legal status under securities law is clear (non-security), but exchanges may choose to delist it under other compliance pressures.

Legal Risks

The chief legal risk for Monero is regulatory ban or restriction. Numerous countries have taken steps specifically against privacy coins. Japan’s Financial Services Agency (FSA) prohibits trading privacy coins on exchanges (Monero: All About the Top Privacy Coin - Chainalysis) (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap). South Korea and Australia have similarly outlawed privacy-centric crypto trading (exchanges delisted XMR) (Monero: All About the Top Privacy Coin - Chainalysis) (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap). Even Dubai’s new crypto framework explicitly bans Monero use (Monero: All About the Top Privacy Coin - Chainalysis). This creates jurisdictional fragmentation: holders might find XMR perfectly legal in some places but illegal to exchange in others. Additionally, international initiatives like FATF’s Travel Rule and AML standards effectively treat privacy coins as high-risk assets. FinCEN (U.S. Treasury) guidance and FATF recommendations require that when privacy coins are transacted, exchanges must still collect customer identity data – indeed, FinCEN states that if a privacy protocol can’t transmit data, firms must send it off-chain ( The Funds Travel Rule and Monero | Monero - secure, private, untraceable ). Non-compliance can lead to fines.

Other legal risks arise from anti-money-laundering (AML) enforcement. Because Monero transactions are private, law enforcement cannot trace them on-chain, making XMR a suspected vehicle for illicit finance. In 2020 the U.S. Internal Revenue Service offered a $625,000 bounty for cracking Monero’s privacy; a firm claimed success (denied by the Monero community) (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap). While Monero’s code has not been legally banned in the U.S., these factors mean that centralized exchanges (especially in regulated countries) may face pressure to drop XMR or limit its flow. In Europe, upcoming MiCA regulations (effective Dec 2024) and new AML rules explicitly ban support for privacy coins. For instance, the EU requires crypto-asset service providers to block privacy coins and disallows merchant payments in tokens like XMR (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure). Indeed, major exchanges like Kraken and Binance are delisting Monero in EU jurisdictions citing these new rules (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure) (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure).

KYC/AML Policies

Monero’s intrinsic privacy means on-chain KYC/AML is impossible: anyone can send XMR without revealing identity. Hence, KYC/AML obligations fall entirely on the fiat on/off ramps (exchanges, kiosks). Regulated exchanges that handle Monero must enforce strict customer identification on their own systems. In practice, many large exchanges either exclude XMR or limit its trading pairings for compliance. Those that do trade XMR typically require full KYC. The FATF travel rule (Recommendation 16) technically applies to XMR transfers above the threshold; FinCEN has clarified that if an on-chain protocol cannot carry identity data, firms must transmit it by other means ( The Funds Travel Rule and Monero | Monero - secure, private, untraceable ). Some projects (e.g. CipherTrace’s TRISA) enable off-chain data exchange to satisfy regulators, but these are optional protocols. Monero itself implements an optional “tx_extra” field that could carry encrypted identity info for compliance, but this adds blockchain bloat and is generally discouraged ( The Funds Travel Rule and Monero | Monero - secure, private, untraceable ).

In summary, Monero must be managed like any other crypto in a regulated business: strict off-chain KYC for users, transaction monitoring for inflows/outflows, and cooperation with authorities for suspicious activity. No standard self-regulatory KYC protocol exists for Monero transactions per se (there’s no fixed issuer); compliance must come from service providers. Because of this friction, many jurisdictions essentially restrict privacy coin exchanges as an AML policy, assuming (often correctly) that truly anonymous coins facilitate money laundering (The Role of Privacy Coins in Crypto Exchanges - SDLC Corp) (The Role of Privacy Coins in Crypto Exchanges - SDLC Corp).

Regulatory Environment

Globally, regulatory attitudes toward Monero are tightening. Several regulators have singled out privacy coins:

• Japan: Banned Monero on all exchanges (FSA guidance).
  
  
• South Korea: Mandated delisting of privacy coins from domestic platforms (The Role of Privacy Coins in Crypto Exchanges - SDLC Corp).
  
  
• Australia: Pressured exchanges to stop listing XMR (some de-listed by 2020) (Monero: All About the Top Privacy Coin - Chainalysis).
  
  
• European Union: Under MiCA/AML, providers cannot offer privacy coins or services, forcing delistings (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure). In 2024 Kraken announced XMR trading cessation in the EEA, citing upcoming MiCA/AML rules (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure) (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure). Binance and OKX have taken similar actions globally (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure).
  
  
• United States: No outright ban on XMR ownership, but regulators (FinCEN, IRS, Treasury) treat it as high-risk for illicit use. U.S. exchanges under AML laws KYC customers but are not prohibited from listing XMR. Coinbase’s policy reflects this caution (no XMR support) (Monero price today, XMR to USD live price, marketcap and chart | CoinMarketCap).
  
  
• Others: Dubai’s new framework bans Monero outright (Monero: All About the Top Privacy Coin - Chainalysis); many major crypto exchanges (e.g. Bittrex, Huobi) stopped XMR trading in U.S. market compliance moves. Meanwhile, law enforcement is actively seeking ways to trace or “crack” privacy coins (see IRS reward) (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap).
  
  

The net effect is a patchwork of regulation: Monero use is effectively illegal or inaccessible via regulated platforms in several Asian and Middle Eastern markets, permitted (with KYC) in North America/Europe but under scrutiny, and ambiguously treated in emerging economies. Privacy coin bans do not eliminate private transactions (just drive them to OTC, P2P, or illegal channels). From a regulatory compliance standpoint, this means any Monero-related business faces significant AML burden and legal uncertainty.

Risk of Regulation

Because of this environment, regulatory risk for XMR is high. New legislation could further criminalize its use, or impose heavy reporting requirements (e.g. UK’s Financial Conduct Authority treating privacy coins as high-risk client crypto). Proposed EU amendments have called for shutting down privacy coins entirely or enforcing backdoors. Even in the U.S., policy could shift: fintech task force reports have singled out privacy coins for restriction. The Tornado Cash court ruling (Mar 2025) showed how U.S. courts may protect privacy tech to some extent (Tornado Cash Ruling Impact on Monero and Privacy Coins - OneSafe Blog), but also highlighted that any crypto protocol can become a legal battlefield, and XMR could face direct legal challenges (e.g. potential designation as contraband under anti-terror laws, though not yet seen).

Privacy and AML

Monero was explicitly designed to preserve privacy, but financial regulators see privacy coins as an “inherent clash” with AML objectives (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap). The EU’s latest AML package effectively treats Monero as a banned instrument in formal finance. In practice, there is no meaningful on-chain AML for XMR, so regulators rely on service-provider controls. In the U.S., FinCEN guidance confirms VASPs must handle privacy coins with the same travel-rule obligations, albeit off-chain ( The Funds Travel Rule and Monero | Monero - secure, private, untraceable ). Notably, after the Tornado Cash ruling, some observers speculate regulators might differentiate between currency (like XMR) and platforms (like mixers) (Tornado Cash Ruling Impact on Monero and Privacy Coins - OneSafe Blog). However, Monero’s privacy features (mandatory stealth addresses, ring signatures) mean any anti-money-laundering strategy must focus on off-chain intelligence and KYC on endpoints. This remains an unresolved tension: technical privacy vs legal transparency.

Notable Legal Events or Precedents

While Monero itself has not been the subject of major court cases, there are several significant incidents:

• Exchange Delistings: The 2021–2024 wave of exchange delistings (Kraken EU, Binance UK, etc.) set precedents for market access restrictions under regulatory pressure (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure) (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure).
  
  
• IRS Bounty (2020): U.S. authorities publicly offered reward for defeating Monero’s privacy, reflecting regulatory focus (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap).
  
  
• CipherTrace Claim (2020): Blockchain analytics firm claimed to trace XMR flows; the Monero community denied full success. While not a legal precedent, it fueled debate on traceability.
  
  
• Tornado Cash Ruling (2025): Though not about Monero directly, the U.S. court decision that overturned sanctions on the Tornado mixer could influence privacy-coin policy. The decision spurred a large XMR price rally and suggests future U.S. nuance toward privacy tech (Tornado Cash Ruling Impact on Monero and Privacy Coins - OneSafe Blog) (Tornado Cash Ruling Impact on Monero and Privacy Coins - OneSafe Blog).
  
  
• EU MiCA Regulation (2024): Officially criminalized privacy-coin payment services in the EU. This regulatory change itself is a precedent shaping how privacy crypto must operate under law (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure).
  
  

No enforcement action has directly targeted a Monero user or developer under laws specific to privacy coins, but the above events set the current legal context. Investors should monitor developments: additional jurisdictional bans or tax reporting rules for Monero could arise.

Summary of Regulatory Risk

Monero’s regulatory risk profile is elevated to high. It operates in a gray area globally: legal to hold/use in some countries (with heavy reporting requirements), but outright banned on trading platforms in others (Monero: All About the Top Privacy Coin - Chainalysis) (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap). Privacy features make it intrinsically suspect to AML authorities, leading to de-listings and restrictions even where ownership isn’t illegal. Compared to mainstream cryptocurrencies, Monero carries extra legal vulnerability. As a quantifiable risk metric, one could note that in markets comprising a large share of global crypto volume (e.g. Japan, South Korea, EU), XMR faces severe constraints or is effectively removed from markets. For an institutional investor, this means Monero could be devalued rapidly by regulatory pronouncements (as seen with Kraken’s 2024 announcement causing a price dip). The ongoing risk is that more countries or financial institutions will treat Monero as non-compliant, possibly even moving to criminalize its exchange or possession (as with certain darknet-associated currencies historically).

Compliance Measures and Security Law Considerations

From a compliance standpoint, Monero-related entities must be proactive. Exchanges that continue to handle XMR typically implement enhanced due diligence on customers, real-time monitoring for suspicious activity (even if transactions are private), and restrict on-chain withdrawals to whitelisted addresses when possible. Some Monero wallet providers have built-in optional audit features (e.g. view key scanning) to help law enforcement if courts request it, though such measures are privacy-neutral and voluntary. Monero’s codebase does not include a “turn-off-privacy” switch like Zcash, so privacy cannot be suspended; all compliance actions are off-chain.

In terms of security law, Monero’s open-source license and decentralized nature mean it is not considered a regulated “product” from a securities law perspective. There is no registration requirement for Monero itself (unlike an ICO token). However, service providers (exchanges, custodians) offering XMR often fall under money transmitter or virtual asset service provider (VASP) laws. For instance, in the U.S. a firm that stores or trades XMR could be a money services business (MSB) subject to FinCEN registration, AML programs, and Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) compliance (including sanction screening, though Monero can be extremely hard to screen on-chain).

In summary, compliance measures revolve around off-chain controls: rigorous KYC/AML on customers, careful regulatory reporting, and legal structuring (e.g. operating in jurisdictions that allow privacy coins under license). Some privacy-focused exchanges attempt partial compliance by requiring KYC even for crypto-to-crypto trades, aiming to satisfy regulators while serving XMR clients. Ultimately, Monero’s design means standard financial regulations (securities law, commodity futures law) have limited applicability, but AML and KYC regulations impose the greatest constraints. Investors should treat Monero exposures with the mindset of “crypto plus high-privacy risk,” ensuring any business handling XMR has robust compliance frameworks and legal analysis for each jurisdiction of operation.

References

1. Chainalysis – All About Monero (XMR), May 2023 (Monero’s privacy tech and use cases) (Monero: All About the Top Privacy Coin - Chainalysis).
   
   
2. CoinMarketCap – Top Privacy Tokens (overview of Monero vs other privacy coins) (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap) (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap).
   
   
3. SDLC Corp – “The Role of Privacy Coins in Crypto Exchanges” (table of regulatory stances) (The Role of Privacy Coins in Crypto Exchanges - SDLC Corp) (The Role of Privacy Coins in Crypto Exchanges - SDLC Corp).
   
   
4. CryptoBriefing – “Kraken to delist Monero in EEA”, Apr 2024 (EU regulation, MiCA impact) (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure) (Kraken to delist Monero in European Economic Area due to regulatory pressure).
   
   
5. Monero Project – “The Funds Travel Rule and Monero”, Dec 2019 (FinCEN guidance) ( The Funds Travel Rule and Monero | Monero - secure, private, untraceable ).
   
   
6. CoinMarketCap – Monero (XMR) page (exchange listings, KYC mention) (Monero price today, XMR to USD live price, marketcap and chart | CoinMarketCap) (Monero price today, XMR to USD live price, marketcap and chart | CoinMarketCap).
   
   
7. CoinMarketCap – Monero FAQ page (network upgrades, privacy features) ( FAQ | Monero - secure, private, untraceable ) ( FAQ | Monero - secure, private, untraceable ).
   
   
8. CoinMarketCap – Crypto News Analysis: Monero Price Spikes 65%, Apr 2025 (market reaction to hack) (Monero (XMR) News Sparks Price Rally - What's the Next Target?).
   
   
9. CoinMarketCap – CoinMarketCap Privacy Coins article (privacy coin bans, IRS bounty) (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap) (Top Privacy Tokens by Market Capitalization | CoinMarketCap).
   
   
10. OneSafe – “Tornado Cash Ruling Impact on Monero”, Mar 2025 (court ruling, market effect) (Tornado Cash Ruling Impact on Monero and Privacy Coins - OneSafe Blog) (Tornado Cash Ruling Impact on Monero and Privacy Coins - OneSafe Blog).
    
    
11. TRM Labs – Glossary: Privacy Coins (technical summary) (Privacy coins | TRM Glossary).
    
    
12. BBC News/CryptoMedia – Regulatory news (2018–2024) (e.g. Japan/South Korea privacy coin bans) (Monero: All About the Top Privacy Coin - Chainalysis) (Monero (XMR) Adoption on the Rise Despite War Against Privacy Coins ).
    
    
13. Monero GitHub – Issue #1079 (malicious node vulnerability discussion) (The Public Remote Node Problem · Issue #1079 · monero-project/meta · GitHub) (The Public Remote Node Problem · Issue #1079 · monero-project/meta · GitHub).
    
    
14. The Next Web – “Monero wallet vulnerability…”, Aug 2018 (exchange wallet security bug) (Monero wallet vulnerability made it possible to steal XMR from exchanges).
    ‍
15. Trend Micro Research – “Vulnerabilities Exploited for Monero Mining Malware”, Dec 2021 (cryptojacking malware) (Vulnerabilities Exploited for Monero Mining Malware Delivered via GitHub, Netlify | Trend Micro (US)) (Vulnerabilities Exploited for Monero Mining Malware Delivered via GitHub, Netlify | Trend Micro (US)).

‍

Thank you for taking the time to read this article. We invite you to explore more content on our blog for additional insights and information.

https://www.thestandard.io/blog  

‍

"If you have any comments, questions, or suggestions, please do not hesitate to reach out to us at [ https://discord.gg/K72hed6FRE ]. We appreciate your feedback and look forward to hearing from you."

‍

CLICK HERE TO CONTINUE

PAGE 9: www.thestandard.io/blog/monero-xmr-report---scaling-new-heights-in-blockchain-performance-2025-portfolio-9